Why New York Families Are Sending Their Children to UK Boarding Schools
3 years ago, a New York parent asking me about English boarding schools was unusual. Now it's a regular conversation. The families I speak to aren't unhappy with Manhattan or Brooklyn schools. Most of them are very happy with them but something has started to make them look further afield and it's worth explaining what.
The teaching at UK boarding schools goes deeper
American high schools ask students to do a bit of everything. That has real strengths, but it can mean a lot of box-ticking and very little time to go deep on the thing a child actually loves. In the British system, students narrow down in Sixth Form to three or four subjects, taken through A-Levels or the IB. A sixteen-year-old who loves history spends two years doing serious history, in a class of eight or ten, with a teacher who often has a degree in the subject from Oxford or Cambridge.
A number of parents have told me their child seemed to "switch on" within a term. I think that's because they were finally being asked to think, not just perform.
Less pressure, or at least a different kind
Anyone who has been through New York admissions knows how early it starts and how much comparing goes on. Test scores, activities, college lists. Children pick it up from the adults around them.
British boarding schools are ambitious places, so I won't pretend otherwise. But the tone is different. Results matter and so do character and what you give back to the community. Parents often say the atmosphere is demanding but calmer.
Living in a community
A boarding school isn't just a school with beds. Children live with their friends and are looked after by housemasters, housemistresses, tutors and matrons who know them well. Meals, evenings and weekends are all part of the school day.
Compare that with the typical evening at home for a teenager: homework and a screen. Many schools also have sensible rules on phones and parents are increasingly grateful for that.
Growing up a bit faster, in a good way
Boarders have to sort out their own time, their own disagreements and their own laundry. They live with people who aren't like them. By eighteen they tend to be more self-reliant than their peers and admissions tutors and employers notice.
Things to do that aren't in a classroom
The top schools have rowing on the Thames, choirs with centuries of history, professional-standard theatres and sports pitches that go on for ages. Because taking part is the norm, children try things they would never have attempted at home. Some of them find something they love.
Friends from everywhere
A New York teenager at a UK boarding school will share a corridor with students from Europe, Asia and the Middle East. Those friendships often last and in a world where careers cross borders, they're useful as well as enjoyable.
It doesn't close the door on US universities
This is the worry I hear most. It's unfounded. Pupils from leading UK schools regularly go on to the Ivy League and other top American universities, as well as Oxford, Cambridge, Imperial and UCL. The options stay open on both sides of the Atlantic and with the right guidance, a British education can make an American application stand out.
The cost
Fees at the top Manhattan day schools now run well into the sixty-thousand-dollar range. UK boarding fees are also substantial, but they include accommodation, meals, activities and pastoral care around the clock and many families conclude the comparison is closer than they expected. Direct flights to London make the distance manageable too.
Is it right for your child?
Not for everyone and the choice of school matters enormously. The UK has its own admissions calendar, its own entrance tests (pre-tests, Common Entrance, school-specific papers), interviews and references. It's easy to miss a deadline, or to misjudge the culture of a school from 3,500 miles away.
That's what CJE Educational Consultancy exists to help with. We work with families to draw up a shortlist, prepare children for assessments, interviews and present each child at their best.
If you're a New York family thinking about UK boarding, get in touch and we can have a confidential conversation about what would suit your child.
Comments